Can a government go into default?

Government debt, commonly referred to as national or sovereign debt, is the total amount borrowed by a nation’s central government to cover the gap between its spending and what it receives from taxes and other sources. One way to think of it is as a gigantic loan, or mortgage, taken out by the entire country to pay for various, necessary public services such as constructing roads or buildings schools, health care services or military defense, or padding the economy during a recession. Debt is not usually owed to one lender; rather, it is divided into different forms, which can broadly be categorized by who the lender is and the currency of the debt. The two primary forms of debt are internal debt, owed to interior lenders, such as compatible citizens, banks, and institutions, and external debt owed to external lenders, such as other countries, international banks, or organizations like the IMEF. It is also important to note the distinction between debt owed in the government’s own currency, meaning it can always theoretically be paid, and the debt owed in a currency used in another country, which is much risk due to the fact it is contingent on the country’s ability to manufacture that currency through trade. Now, can governments not repay that debt?

Certainly, and that situation is referred to as a default. In the simplest terms, a default is similar to a person going bankrupt; it means the government has run out of money and can no longer afford to pay interest or repay the original loan amount to its lenders. Defaults are rare. But when they do happen, they cause an enormous loss of confidence, which makes it very difficult and expensive to for the country to borrow money in the future and it can trigger a severe economic crisis for the citizens of that country.

What is Government debt?

Government debt (or public debt, or national debt) is the total amount of money that the government owes to creditors, usually as a result of borrowing to finance its budget deficits (when spending exceeds revenue). It is the total result of borrowing through the issuing of securities (debt issuance or bonds) or loans to help finance expenses (infrastructure, welfare, or expenses related to emergencies).

Types of Government debt

Internal Debt:

Debt to creditors inside the country such as domestic banks, financial institutions, or citizens buying government bonds (like, say, American investors buying U.S. Treasury bonds).

External Debt:

Debt owed to foreign creditors, including foreign governments, international organizations (e.g., IMF, World Bank), or foreign investors.

Short-Term Debt:

Short-term debt is money a government needs to pay back very quickly, usually within a year or less. It’s like using a credit card to cover immediate bills before your next paycheck arrives.

Long-Term Debt:

Debt with a maturity exceeding one year, typically issued as bonds to finance long-term projects like infrastructure.

Secured Debt:

Debt backed by specific assets or revenue streams (e.g., revenue bonds tied to tolls or taxes).

Unsecured Debt:

Debt not backed by specific collateral, relying on the government’s creditworthiness (most sovereign bonds fall here).

Contingent Debt:

Implicit or explicit obligations that may become actual debt under certain conditions, like government guarantees for loans or bailouts.

Publicly Held Debt:

Debt held by private entities, individuals, or foreign governments, excluding debt held by government trust funds (e.g., Social Security in the U.S.).

Intragovernmental Debt:

Debt a government owes to its own agencies or trust funds, such as borrowing from pension funds or social security reserves.

Can a government go into default?

Indeed, a government can default on its obligations, though it is uncommon for significant economic nations. A sovereign default is the failure of a government to meet its obligation on its debt through non-payment of interest or failure to repay the principal. Defaulting dues can be partial (failure to pay some) or complete (defaulting on all repayment).

Scenarios Leading to Default:

• Political Decisions: A government may choose to default for political reasons, refusing to honor debt (e.g., Russia’s 1918 Bolshevik debt repudiation).
• Inability to Pay: If a government’s revenue (taxes, etc.) cannot cover debt obligations, and it cannot borrow more due to loss of creditor confidence.
• Currency Constraints: Countries borrowing in foreign currencies (e.g., U.S. dollars) may default if they lack foreign exchange reserves, as they cannot print foreign currency (e.g., Argentina’s 2001 default).
• Economic Crises: Severe recessions, hyperinflation, or external shocks (e.g., commodity price collapses) can strain finances, leading to default (e.g., Greece’s 2012 debt restructuring).

Examples of Sovereign Defaults:

• Argentina (2001, 2020):
  • Argentina’s two major defaults arose from serious and persistent economic problems but took place rather differently. The first, the default of 2001, was the largest default in history at the time, and it represented the dramatic eruption of a long-simmering crisis. The government had borrowed huge amounts of money at the same time that it pegged its currency one-to-one with the U.S. dollar. Eventually, the economy collapsed and it could no longer pay its debts. It resulted in half-frozen bank accounts, huge protests, and the catastrophic default that wiped out the savings of thousands of people. It took years of painful litigation with creditors thereafter to reach a resolution.
  • Meanwhile, the default of 2020 was much more of a managed collapse. Argentina was already in a recession, suffering from hyper-inflation, and was unable to pay its debts. The COVID Pandemic was the final push that forced it over the edge. Instead of a frantic collapse, the state entered into negotiations with its creditors to agree on restructuring the debt, inviting them to accept longer repayment terms with lower interest rates in the interests of avoiding something much worse. While it was still a default, it was a more orderly process aimed at relief, to try to bring the economy back on track.
• Russia (1998):
  • In 1998, Russia suffered a massive sovereign default; in other words, the government was unable to pay its debts. The primary factors that drove this crisis were the combination of large amounts of government debt, a hurtle global oil price (which negatively affected Russia as its main products were oil), and the aftershock of the Asia financial crisis that decreased investor faith in emerging markets. To peg the exchange rate of the ruble, the Russian government used billions of its foreign reserves; however, they were unable to continue this effort . On August 17, 1998, the government announced a devaluation of the ruble, defaulted on their domestic debt, and imposed a 90-day ban on foreign debts. The ruble lost over two-thirds of its value, inflation rose to around 84%, and many banks failed, causing widespread economic dissatisfaction and civil unrest. Ultimately, Russia emerged relatively quickly from the crisis due to a weak ruins supporting exports and rising oil prices; however, the crisis highlighted the deep structural problems in the Russia economy.

Conclusion

To conclude, there are many forms of government debt depending on the source, term and backing. Defaults are possible, but are less likely in countries with strong economies and currency control when they occur, there are serious economic and political ramifications.

FAQs